The short answer: two farm toppers, one clear split
Both the Draft Plow Horse Mailbox Topper and the Mule Mailbox Topper are laser-cut from 14-gauge steel, finished with an outdoor-grade powder coat, and supplied with stainless steel mounting hardware. Each is approximately 12” long and designed to sit on top of a mailbox using a bend (flange) at the bottom. The practical choice comes down to design preference, current price, and how much of a statement you want at the curb.
If you want the draft-horse silhouette and a slightly larger catalog price, the Draft Plow Horse is the pick. If you prefer the mule profile or want the lower catalog price, the Mule is the better fit. Neither is confirmed by the supplied information as having a different mounting method, finish, or material—so the decision is mostly about the artwork and your budget.
What both toppers share
- Draft Plow Horse Mailbox Topper: Laser-cut from 14-gauge steel with an outdoor-grade powder coat finish. These are the construction details that matter for a driveway piece exposed to weather.

Draft Plow Horse Mailbox Topper - Mule Mailbox Topper: Laser-cut from 14-gauge steel with an outdoor-grade powder coat finish. The Mule uses the same base material and finish, so durability is not a differentiator between the two.

Mule Mailbox Topper - Draft Plow Horse Mailbox Topper: Includes a bend (flange) at the bottom for mounting on top of the mailbox, plus stainless steel mounting hardware. This tells you how the topper attaches and what comes in the box.
- Mule Mailbox Topper: Includes a bend (flange) at the bottom for mounting on top of the mailbox, plus stainless steel mounting hardware. The Mule mounts the same way, so installation effort should be comparable.
Draft Plow Horse vs. Mule: the differences that matter
The supplied records show the same material, finish, approximate length, mounting flange, and hardware for both toppers. The meaningful differences are the design and the catalog price.
- Design: Draft Plow Horse shows a plow horse; Mule shows a mule. Both are hand-drawn JE3 artwork exclusive to the brand.
- Approximate length: Both are listed as approximately 12” long. This is a catalog approximation, not a precise measurement.
- Catalog price: Draft Plow Horse is listed at USD 21.54 (comparison price USD 29.50); Mule is listed at USD 18.00 (comparison price USD 29.50). Prices can change, so confirm at checkout.
- Color: Both list a Black variant. No other colors are confirmed in the supplied variant evidence.
- Mounting: Both use a bottom flange and stainless steel hardware. The supplied information does not specify a particular mailbox material or post type, so check your mailbox top before ordering.
How to choose for your driveway
Start with the mailbox itself. Because both toppers are approximately 12” long and mount with a bottom flange, measure the flat top area of your mailbox and confirm you have room for the flange and hardware. The supplied information does not list a required mailbox size or shape, so this is a fit check you do on your own mailbox rather than a manufacturer specification.
Then decide on the silhouette. A horse mailbox topper reads as classic farm equipment; a mule mailbox topper reads as a slightly more unusual rural character. If your driveway already has a strong equine theme, the Draft Plow Horse keeps it consistent. If you want a farm mailbox topper that stands out from the usual horse motif, the Mule is the obvious alternative.
Finally, check the price you will actually pay. The Mule has the lower catalog price in the supplied records, but both show the same comparison price. Treat those numbers as catalog data to verify at checkout, not as a permanent guarantee.
Practical checks before you order
- Mailbox top space: The topper is approximately 12” long and uses a bottom flange. Confirm your mailbox top can accommodate that footprint and the included hardware.
- Finish expectations: Both have an outdoor-grade powder coat. The supplied information does not give a warranty period or a cleaning schedule, so avoid assuming either.
- Color availability: Black is the only variant shown in the supplied evidence. If you need another color, confirm with the store before ordering.
- Gift timing: Both are described as memorable gifts. If you are buying for a deadline, check current shipping details with the store rather than relying on a general estimate.
Catalog details for each topper
- Draft Plow Horse Mailbox Topper: Draft Plow Horse Mailbox Topper: approximately 12” long, 14-gauge steel, outdoor-grade powder coat, stainless steel hardware, Black variant, catalog price USD 21.54 (comparison USD 29.50). This is the full supplied snapshot for the horse design so you can compare it directly with the Mule.
- Mule Mailbox Topper: Mule Mailbox Topper: approximately 12” long, 14-gauge steel, outdoor-grade powder coat, stainless steel hardware, Black variant, catalog price USD 18.00 (comparison USD 29.50). This is the full supplied snapshot for the mule design, including the lower catalog price.



